Infilling in German cities. Analysing the extent and spatial distribution of infilling and its effects on housing density between 1991 and 2011

Sebastian Eichhorn

doi:10.3112/erdkunde.2024.02.03

Authors

Sebastian Eichhorn https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3825-0614

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.3112/erdkunde.2024.02.03

Keywords:

infilling, residential construction activity, GIS analysis, evaluation, Global Human Settlement Layer (GHSL), census

Abstract

Infilling is considered one of the most important planning principles worldwide to reduce urban growth and urban sprawl. This also applies to Germany. However, due to a lack of nationwide small-scale data, there are hardly any empirical findings on how infilling has taken place in German cities. Using a newly developed GIS-based algorithm and small-scale data on residential construction activity (100x100m grid cells) and built-up areas, we analyse how residential development has evolved in 30 German case studies over a study period from 1991 to 2011. Within concentric 1km rings, our analysis differentiates residential construction activity by infilling, building types, land cover and housing density. Using cluster analysis, we further group the case studies into more homogeneous groups. The findings show that infilling has been pursued and implemented by most of the case studies since the 1990s. However, it becomes clear that there are large differences in the extent of infilling and that it does not necessarily lead to an increase in housing density. The findings show - in addition to national regulations and guidelines as well as population development - that it is primarily the structural framework conditions, the specific commitment of the municipalities as well as local and regional challenges that determine the type of residential construction activity.

References

Akan T, Solle T (2022) Do macroeconomic and financial governance matter? Evidence from Germany, 1950–2019. Journal of Economic Interaction and Coordination 17: 993–1045.

Altrock U (2022) New (sub)urbanism? - How German cities try to create “urban” neighborhoods in their outskirts as a contribution to solving their recent housing crises. Urban Governance 2: 130–143.

BBSR (Federal Office for Building and Regional Planning) (2022) Bauland- und Innenentwicklungspotenziale in deutschen Städten und Gemeinden. Bonn.

Behnisch M, Krüger T, Jaeger JAG (2022) Rapid rise in urban sprawl: Global hotspots and trends since 1990. PLOS Sustainability and Transformation 1: e0000034.

Berghauser Pont M, Haupt P, Berg P, Alstäde V, Heyman A (2021) Systematic review and comparison of densification effects and planning motivations. Buildings and Cities 2: 378.

Bibby P, Henneberry J, Halleux J-M (2020) Under the radar? ‘Soft’ residential densification in England, 2001–2011. Environment and Planning B: Urban Analytics and City Science 47: 102–118.

BMI (Federal Ministry of the Interior) (1985) Bodenschutzkonzeption der Bundesregierung. Bundestags-Drucksache. Bonn.

Broitman D, Koomen E (2015) Residential density change: Densification and urban expansion. Computers, Environment and Urban Systems 54: 32–46.

Broitman D, Koomen E (2020) The attraction of urban cores: Densification in Dutch city centres. Urban Studies 57: 1920–1939.

Chakraborty S, Dadashpoor H, Novotný J, Maity I, Follmann A, Patel PP, Roy U, Pramanik S (2022a) In pursuit of sustainability – Spatio-temporal pathways of urban growth patterns in the world’s largest megacities. Cities 131: 103919.

Chakraborty S, Maity I, Dadashpoor H, Novotný J, Banerji S (2022b) Building in or out? Examining urban expansion patterns and land use efficiency across the global sample of 466 cities with million+ inhabitants. Habitat International 120: 102503.

Chakraborty S, Pramanik S, Follmann A, Giri B, Mondal B, Patel PP, Maity I, Das J, Punia M, Sahana M (2021) Dominant urban form and its relation to nighttime land surface temperature in the rapidly urbanizing National Capital Region of India. Urban Climate 40: 101002.

Claassens J, Koomen E, Rouwendal J (2020) Urban density and spatial planning: The unforeseen impacts of Dutch devolution. PLOS ONE 15: e0240738.

Corbane C, Pesaresi M, Kemper T, Politis P, Florczyk AJ, Syrris V, Melchiorri M, Sabo F, Soille P (2019) Automated global delineation of human settlements from 40 years of Landsat satellite data archives. Big Earth Data 3: 140–169.

Deutsche Bundesbank (2002) The housing market during the nineties. Monthly Report. Frankfurt am Main.

Deutscher Bundestag (1971) Umweltprogramm der Bundesregierung. Bundestags-Drucksache. Bonn.

Die Bundesregierung (2021) Deutsche Nachhaltigkeitsstrategie - Weiterentwicklung 2021. Berlin.

Dorffmeister L (2017) Construction of 1+2 family homes in Germany: Is the golden age over? CESifo Forum 18: 37–42. .

Eichhorn S (2023) Infilling in Germany. Estimating the extent of infilling in German municipalities between 1979 and 2011. Landscape and Urban Planning 240: 104895.

Eichhorn S, Ehrhardt D, Münter A, Behnisch M, Jehling M (2024) Understanding land take by low-density residential areas. an institutionalist perspective on local planning authorities, developers and households. Land Use Policy.

Eichhorn S, Rusche K, Weith T (2021) Integrative governance processes towards sustainable spatial development – solving conflicts between urban infill development and climate change adaptation. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 64: 2233–2256.

Eichhorn S, Siedentop S (2022a) Innen vor Außen? Eine Schätzung der Innenentwicklung in nordrhein-westfälischen Gemeinden, 1979 bis 2011. Raumforschung und Raumordnung.

Eichhorn S, Siedentop S (2022b) Innenentwicklung in Deutschland - ein Klassifizierungsansatz. Meinel G, Krüger T, Behnisch M, Ehrhardt D (eds) Flächennutzungsmonitoring XIV. Beiträge zu Flächenmanagement, Daten, Methoden und Analysen: 139–148. Berlin.

European Commission (EC) (2023) CORINE Land Cover. .

EUROPEAN COMMISSION (EC) (2011) Roadmap to a resource efficient Europe. COM(2011) 571. Brussels.

EUROPEAN COMMISSION (EC) (2006) Soil Thematic Strategy. COM(2006) 231. Brussels.

Ewing R, Cervero R (2017) “Does compact development make people drive less?” The answer is yes. Journal of the American Planning Association 83: 19–25.

Ewing R, Lyons T, Siddiq F, Sabouri S, Kiani F, Hamidi S, Choi D, Ameli H (2022) Growth management effectiveness: A literature review. Journal of Planning Literature 37: 433–451.

Gerten C, Fina S, Rusche K (2019) The sprawling planet: Simplifying the measurement of global urbanization trends. Frontiers in Environmental Science 7: 140.

Götze V, Jehling M (2022) Comparing types and patterns: A context-oriented approach to densification in Switzerland and the Netherlands. Environment and Planning B: Urban Analytics and City Science: 239980832211421.

Greiving S, Flex F, Terfrüchte T (2022) Vergleichende Untersuchung der Zentrale-Orte-Konzepte in den Ländern und Empfehlungen zu ihrer Weiterentwicklung. Raumforschung und Raumordnung 73: 285–297.

Hortas-Rico M, Solé-Ollé A (2010) Does urban sprawl increase the costs of providing local public services? Evidence from Spanish municipalities. Urban Studies 47: 1513–1540.

Jehling M, Hecht R, Herold H (2018) Assessing urban containment policies within a suburban context—An approach to enable a regional perspective. Land Use Policy 77: 846–858.

Kodinariya T, Makwana PR (2013) Review on determining number of cluster in K-Means clustering. International Journal of Advance Research in

Computer Science and Management Studies 1: 90–95.

Mohajeri N, Walch A, Smith A, Gudmundsson A, Assouline D, Russel T, Hall J (2023) A machine learning methodology to quantify the potential of urban densification in the Oxford-Cambridge Arc, United Kingdom. Sustainable Cities and Society: 104451.

Mouratidis K (2018) Is compact city livable? The impact of compact versus sprawled neighbourhoods on neighbourhood satisfaction. Urban Studies 55: 2408–2430.

Mustafa A, van Rompaey A, Cools M, Saadi I, Teller J (2018) Addressing the determinants of built-up expansion and densification processes at the regional scale. Urban Studies 55: 3279–3298.

Novotný J, Chakraborty S, Maity I (2022) Urban expansion of the 43 worlds’ largest megacities: A search for unified macro-patterns. Habitat International 129: 102676.

Osterhage F (2018) The end of reurbanisation? Phases of concentration and deconcentration in migratory movements in North Rhine-Westphalia. Comparative Population Studies 43: 131-15.

Reiß-Schmidt S (2018) Innenentwicklung. ARL – Akademie für Raumforschung und Landesplanung (ed) Handwörterbuch der Stadt- und Raumentwicklung: 995–1000. Hannover

Schiller G, Blum A, Hecht R, Oertel H, Ferber U, Meinel G (2021) Urban infill development potential in Germany: Comparing survey and GIS data. Buildings and Cities 2: 36–54.

Siedentop S (2008) Siedlungspolitischer Kontext des 30-Hektar-Ziels. Köck W, Bizer K, Hansjürgens B, Einig K, Siedentop S (eds) Handelbare Flächenausweisungsrechte: 21–35.

Siedentop S, Schmidt S, Dunlop A (2022) Managing urban growth – an overview of the literature. Raumforschung und Raumordnung 80: 659–677.

Statistisches Bundesamt (Destatis) (2010) 2011 Census. .

Storm S, Naastepad C (2015) Crisis and recovery in the German economy: The real lessons. Structural Change and Economic Dynamics 32: 11–24.

Thorne JH, Santos MJ, Bjorkman J, Soong O, Ikegami M, Seo C, Hannah L (2017) Does infill outperform climate-adaptive growth policies in meeting sustainable urbanization goals? A scenario-based study in California, USA. Landscape and Urban Planning 157: 483–492.

Wolff M, Wiechmann T (2018) Urban growth and decline: Europe’s shrinking cities in a comparative perspective 1990–2010. European Urban and Regional Studies 25: 122–139.